NY Landscape

Eric Garner's Disciplinary Hearing Brings Up More Problems For NYPD


New details have emerged relating to the death of Eric Garner at the hands of a NYPD officer during the disciplinary hearing brought by the Civilian Complaint Review Board (“CCRB”) for Officer Daniel Pantaleo - the officer responsible for placing Garner in a chokehold. Sadly, they reveal a myriad of problems for NYPD.

Notably, after receiving a text message from one of his officers stating that Eric Garner had been arrested and was “most likely DOA”, lieutenant Christopher Bannon responded saying it was “not a big deal, we were effecting a lawful arrest.” Lieutenant Bannon will likely not face any disciplinary action for his response, due to the statute of limitations on administrative charges.

The chokehold tactic that was used on Eric Garner continues to be used by the NYPD, despite a $35 million effort by NYPD to retrain patrol officers not to employ strangleholds. According to a New York Times article, 133 complaints of chokeholds were filed last year although this is the fewest in a decade.

Officer Pantaleo faces charges of reckless use of a chokehold and intentional restriction of breathing in a hearing brought by the independent police watchdog agency, the CCRB, which began in May 2019. Pantaleo’s lawyer alleges that the tactic used on Garner was a seatbelt technique that is taught to NYPD officers in training. During the first day of Pantaleo’s trial, it was revealed by internal affairs investigators that the officer who wrestled Garner to the ground used a forbidden chokehold on him, according to a police supervisor’s testimony. This testimony is troublesome for NYPD, who never took independent action against Pantaleo and only chose to place Pantaleo on desk duty. According to a New York Times article, the supervisor who oversaw the NYPD’s internal review testified that in 2015 he ordered the lead investigator to recommend disciplinary charges against Officer Pantaleo, but the department’s internal prosecution unit never filed charges.

On Wednesday, May 15, 2019, the doctor who performed an autopsy on Eric Garner testified during Pantaleo’s disciplinary hearing that a police officer choked Garner with enough force that it triggered a “lethal cascade” of events, ending in a fatal asthma attack, according to a New York Times article. This marks the third official to testify that Pantaleo used a prohibited chokehold on Garner. Further, the commanding officer of the police academy, Deputy Inspector Richard Dee, testified that video footage of Pantaleo taking down Garner meets the definition of a chokehold. Dee also testified that the seatbelt maneuver was not taught in the academy in 2006, when Pantaleo went through the academy.

A witness to Garner’s death will not testify in Pantaleo’s disciplinary hearing, saying the hearing trivializes Garner’s death. The hearing is to determine whether Pantaleo violated departmental rules and should be subject to punishment, but the hearing fails to consider larger issues that led to Garner’s death that the NYPD still faces, like leadership, expectations placed on officers, police culture, race and community complaints, according to a New York Times article.

If you have been the victim of police brutality or misconduct or a false arrest by NYPD, contact the attorneys at PetersonDelleCave LLP for a free consultation.

Client Reviews
I can't express how much Peterson Delle Cave LLP helped me and my family gain justice against the two NYPD cops who abused us. It was immediately obvious that Duncan and Malcolm were extremely experienced in handling cases against NYPD. They clearly explained to me how to sue NYPD, and were up front and clear about the length and difficulty of filing a lawsuit. They kept me informed throughout the entire process and their responses were always timely and thorough. I was very happy with the outcome and results they achieved for me and my family. I would recommend PetersonDelleCave LLP to anyone that wants to sue NYPD. L.D.
At first I was hesitant to contact a law firm I found on the internet, but from the moment I first visited PetersonDelleCave LLP’s Manhattan office I knew I had made the right choice. Mr. Delle Cave is a friendly, knowledgeable attorney who negotiated with the City’s lawyers and obtained a settlement in my case that exceeded my expectations. J. T.
From the beginning to the end of my case, Mr. Peterson was kind, understanding, and always available. He always made sure I understood every step of my case. I could not have asked for a more knowledgeable, responsive, hard-working attorney to represent me against the NYPD. I. J.